What “net cost” means here
Buying: down payment and closing costs, plus every year’s mortgage payments, property tax, insurance, maintenance, and HOA dues — minus what you would walk away with if you sold (sale price, less selling costs, less the remaining loan balance).
Renting: every year’s rent and renters insurance — minus the investment gain on the cash you did not spend on a down payment and closing costs.
The option with the lower net cost over your time horizon comes out ahead financially under these assumptions.
Why time matters most
Buying has large one-time costs at both ends. Over a short stay those costs are spread across few years, which favors renting. Over a longer stay, equity and appreciation have time to offset them. The year-by-year table shows where the lines cross for your inputs.
Limits of this model
- Income tax effects, such as the mortgage interest deduction, are not included.
- Property tax and maintenance follow the home’s value; insurance and HOA dues are held flat.
- The renter invests the upfront cash once. Monthly differences between the two options are not invested.
- Appreciation, rent growth, and investment returns are steady. Real markets are not.
- Non-financial factors — stability, flexibility, control over the space — are yours to weigh.
Common questions
What appreciation rate should I use?
There is no reliable way to predict it for one home. Try a low, middle, and high value and see whether the answer changes. If it flips easily, the decision is close on financial grounds.
Why include an investment return for renting?
Cash used for a down payment can’t be invested elsewhere. Counting what it could earn makes the comparison fairer to renting.
Reviewed October 2026. Methodology
