DIY vs Contractor Calculator

Compare a contractor’s quote with what DIY really costs once tools, mistakes, and your own time are counted.

The starting values are examples. Replace them with your quote and your own estimates.

Hiring a contractor
$

Labor and materials.

Doing it yourself
$

$

$

%

Extra materials for errors and redos, as a percent of materials.

hrs

$/hr

Set to 0 to ignore your time.

Your result will appear here.

How the comparison works

DIY out of pocket = materials + tools + fees + (materials × mistake allowance)

DIY full cost = out of pocket + (hours × value of your time)

The most useful number is often savings per hour you work: the cash you keep by not hiring, divided by the hours it takes. If that figure is higher than what your free time is worth to you, DIY makes financial sense.

Estimating honestly

  • Hours — include planning, shopping trips, setup, cleanup, and learning. First-time projects routinely take two or three times longer than expected.
  • Tools — count what you need to buy or rent, less anything you will truly reuse.
  • Mistakes — a miscut board or a second coat of the wrong paint is normal. Skilled work such as tile and drywall finishing has a steeper learning curve.
  • The quote — make sure it covers the same scope and material quality you are pricing for DIY.

When not to DIY, whatever the math says

Some work is restricted to licensed professionals or requires permits and inspections: most gas, electrical service, and structural work, and in many places plumbing. Roof work and anything at height carries serious fall risk. Homes built before 1978 may contain lead paint, and older materials may contain asbestos; disturbing either has legal and health implications. Mistakes in these areas can also affect insurance claims and resale.

The DIY vs contractor guide covers how to decide and how to vet a contractor.

Common questions

What should I use for the value of my time?

There is no right answer. Some people use their after-tax hourly pay; others use a lower figure because they enjoy the work, or a higher one because free time is scarce. Try a few values.

Can I do part of the job myself?

Often. Demolition, painting, and cleanup are common tasks homeowners take on to reduce a contractor’s bill. Agree on it in writing so responsibilities are clear.

Reviewed October 2026. Methodology