Repair vs Replace Calculator

Enter your repair quote and what a replacement would cost. You get a clear lean toward repair or replacement, the reasons behind it, and the most the repair is reasonably worth.

The starting values are an example. Replace them with your own quote and a local replacement price.

What needs repair

Tells the tool whether this is a routine part or a core component.

yrs

yrs

Published range for this type: 7–15 years. Adjust for your unit’s build quality, upkeep, and conditions.

Your quotes
$

The written quote, including parts and labor.

$

A comparable new unit, installed. Use a real quote if you can.

$/yr

Optional. Lower energy or maintenance bills, if you have an estimate.

Your result will appear here.

A planning tool, not a diagnosis

This calculator weighs the numbers you enter. It cannot inspect your equipment, confirm what failed, or judge whether it is safe to run. Repair and replacement prices vary with your location and local labor rates, the brand and model, how hard the equipment is to reach, installation requirements, material costs, and the contractor you hire, which is why you enter your own quotes here.

For anything involving gas, combustion, refrigerant, or electrical parts, rely on a licensed professional’s inspection. How our tools work.

Where these numbers come from

Scope: United States. Lifespans are general guidelines for equipment that receives regular maintenance under normal conditions. They are not predictions for any individual unit. Last compared with the source: October 5, 2026.

How we use it: The starting lifespan for each type is the midpoint of the published range, chosen by MyHomeMetric. The visitor can change it. Each part is classed by MyHomeMetric as a wear part, a major part, or a core component. The classes are a general judgment, not a published standard. The planning score, its weights, and its bands are a MyHomeMetric decision model. They are not an industry standard. The 50% guideline and the $5,000 HVAC guideline are common rules of thumb. The 50% guideline sets one of the two repair ceilings; the $5,000 guideline is shown for reference only and does not change the score.

MyHomeMetric is not affiliated with or endorsed by the publishers named.

What this calculator does

A repair quote is a number without context. This tool supplies the context: how big the repair is next to the price of new, how much service life the repair is likely to buy, and what each option costs per year of use. It then gives you three things:

  • A lean — toward repair, toward replacement, or borderline.
  • A repair ceiling — the most the repair is reasonably worth on the numbers you entered, which is useful when you negotiate or compare quotes.
  • The reasoning — every figure behind the result, so you can check it and challenge it.

It works for central air conditioners, furnaces, heat pumps, tank water heaters, and major appliances, and for anything else if you enter its expected lifespan.

How the decision is calculated

Four things go into the result.

1. Repair cost next to replacement cost

Repair share = repair quote ÷ installed replacement cost

The larger the share, the more you are paying toward the price of new while keeping every other original part.

2. Age and remaining useful life

Remaining life = expected lifespan − current age

The same repair buys far less on equipment near the end of its life. The expected lifespan starts at the midpoint of a published range for that type of equipment, and you can change it. Shorten it for builder-grade equipment, hard water, coastal air, or heavy use. Lengthen it for well-maintained, higher-quality equipment, or when a technician who has seen the unit expects more.

3. Cost per year

Repair per year = repair quote ÷ remaining years

Replacement per year = replacement cost ÷ expected lifespan − yearly savings

This puts both options on the same footing. If the unit is at or past its expected lifespan, the tool assumes the repair buys at least one more year so the math stays meaningful.

4. What failed

Parts are grouped as wear parts (igniters, capacitors, belts, gaskets, drain pumps), major parts (motors, control boards, valves), and core components (compressors, heat exchangers, tanks, drum bearings). A wear part failing says little about the rest of the machine. A core component failing on older equipment often does. These groupings are our general judgment, not a published standard.

What the score means

The planning score runs from 0 to 100. It starts at 100 and loses up to 40 points for the size of the repair, up to 30 for the share of life already used, up to 20 for the cost-per-year comparison, and up to 10 for the type of part.

  • 65 to 100 — leans repair. The repair is small next to replacement and the equipment has useful life ahead.
  • 40 to 64 — borderline. The numbers do not settle it. Price, the technician’s view of the unit’s condition, and your own plans should decide.
  • 0 to 39 — leans replace. The repair is expensive for the service life it is likely to buy.

The score, its weights, and its bands are MyHomeMetric’s own decision model. It is a way to organize the numbers, not an industry standard, and two reasonable people could weight these factors differently. That is why the result page shows every deduction.

The repair ceiling

The ceiling is the lower of two amounts:

  • The cost-per-year break-even. Replacement cost per year × remaining years. Above this, each remaining year of the old unit costs more than a year of a new one. This is arithmetic on your own figures.
  • Half the replacement cost. The widely used 50% guideline, described below.

If your quote is above the ceiling, that does not mean the technician is overcharging. It means that at this price, on these numbers, the money goes further toward a replacement. A lower quote, a cheaper repair option, or a longer expected life can each bring a repair back under the line.

About the rules of thumb

The 50% guideline says to think hard about replacing when a single repair costs more than half the price of a comparable new unit. It is a long-standing consumer rule of thumb. It is simple and often sensible, but it ignores age: half the price of new is a very different deal on a three-year-old unit than on a twelve-year-old one. That is why this tool uses it alongside the cost-per-year math and never alone.

The $5,000 HVAC guideline is a shortcut some heating and cooling contractors quote: multiply the system’s age by the repair cost, and if the result is over $5,000, consider replacing. It combines age and cost in one step, but the $5,000 figure is arbitrary, is not adjusted for inflation or for the size of the system, and is not an official standard. We show the result for reference and do not let it change the score.

Age guidance from ENERGY STAR. For heating and cooling equipment, ENERGY STAR suggests considering replacement when a heat pump or air conditioner is more than 10 years old, or a furnace or boiler is more than 15 years old, among other signs such as frequent repairs and rising energy bills. That is guidance about when to start weighing a replacement, not an instruction to replace working equipment.

Worked example

A nine-year-old central air conditioner needs a new condenser fan motor. The quote is $1,500. A comparable new system would cost $7,500 installed, and the owner keeps the starting 11-year expected lifespan.

  • Repair share: $1,500 ÷ $7,500 = 20%.
  • Remaining life: 11 − 9 = 2 years.
  • Repair per year: $1,500 ÷ 2 = $750.
  • Replacement per year: $7,500 ÷ 11 = $682.
  • Break-even: $682 × 2 = $1,364. Half of replacement is $3,750, so the ceiling is the lower figure, rounded down to $1,360.

The score comes out at 52, borderline, and the quote is $140 over the ceiling. Now suppose the technician says the system is in good shape and should last to 15 years. Remaining life becomes 6 years, the repair drops to $250 a year, and the score rises to 67, leaning repair. The expected lifespan is the input most worth a professional opinion.

When repair usually makes sense

  • The equipment is in the first half of its expected life.
  • The failed part is a routine wear part and the rest of the unit is in good condition.
  • The repair is a small share of replacement cost.
  • The part or labor is covered by a warranty.
  • A replacement would require other costly work, such as new ductwork, venting, or electrical upgrades, that you are not ready to take on.
  • You need time to plan and save for a replacement on your own schedule.

When replacement may make sense

  • The equipment is near or past its expected lifespan and this is not its first significant repair.
  • A core component has failed on older equipment.
  • The repair is a large share of replacement cost, or well above the ceiling.
  • A new unit would noticeably lower your energy bills, or rebates and tax credits reduce its price.
  • Parts are discontinued or hard to get. For example, the U.S. EPA notes that no new R-22 refrigerant has been made or imported since January 1, 2020, so older air conditioners that use it depend on recovered and stockpiled supply. The EPA does not require homeowners to replace that equipment.
  • A licensed professional has found a safety problem, such as a cracked heat exchanger or a leaking tank.

When to get a second quote

A second opinion costs a service-call fee and is usually worth it when:

  • the result is borderline, or the quote is above the repair ceiling;
  • the repair is expensive in absolute terms;
  • the diagnosis is a core component, such as a compressor or heat exchanger;
  • you were told the equipment must be replaced immediately, especially by a company that also sells replacements;
  • the quote is a single lump sum with no parts and labor breakdown.

For replacement, collect two or three written quotes for comparable equipment. Use the HVAC Replacement Cost Estimator or the Water Heater Cost Estimator to see published national ranges before the quotes arrive.

Questions to ask the contractor

  • What exactly failed, and what caused it?
  • Can I have the quote in writing, with parts and labor listed separately?
  • After this repair, how many more years do you expect from the unit? What is likely to fail next?
  • Is the part, or the unit, still under warranty? What warranty comes with the repair?
  • Is there a less expensive repair option, and what are its drawbacks?
  • Is the equipment safe to keep using in the meantime?
  • If I replace it, what would a comparable unit cost installed, and what else would the job require?
  • Are you licensed and insured for this work, and will you pull any permit it needs?

What the calculator cannot know

  • The real condition of your equipment. A well-maintained unit can outlast its expected lifespan by years. A neglected one can fail early.
  • Whether the diagnosis is right. The tool takes the failed part as given.
  • Safety. It does not evaluate gas, combustion, electrical, or refrigerant hazards.
  • Your local prices. You supply the repair quote and the replacement cost, because both vary widely by area, brand, model, access, and contractor.
  • Future repairs. It weighs this repair only. A string of earlier repairs is a reason to lean further toward replacement than the score suggests.
  • Your circumstances. How long you will stay in the home, whether you can fund a replacement now, comfort, noise, and reliability all matter and are yours to weigh.

Assumptions and limits

  • Expected lifespans start from the ranges in InterNACHI’s published life expectancy chart, which assume regular maintenance and normal conditions and are described by their publisher as guidelines only. The starting value is the midpoint of the range, chosen by us.
  • Costs are spread evenly over years of service. Interest, inflation, and the resale value of the home are not included.
  • Running-cost savings count only if you enter them. The tool does not estimate energy savings for you.
  • The tool contains no repair or replacement prices of its own.
  • The score’s weights and bands are planning assumptions. They are stored separately from the calculator so they can be reviewed and revised.

For planned upkeep, the home maintenance budget guide shows how to set money aside before something fails. For roofs, which follow a different logic, see the Roof Repair Cost Estimator and the roof replacement guide.

Common questions

Is the 50% rule an official standard?

No. It is a common rule of thumb: when one repair costs more than half the price of a comparable new unit, replacement deserves serious consideration. It ignores age, so this calculator pairs it with a cost-per-year comparison.

What is the $5,000 rule for HVAC repairs?

A shortcut some contractors use: multiply the system’s age in years by the repair cost, and if the result is above $5,000, consider replacing. It is not an official standard and the figure is arbitrary, so this tool shows it for reference without letting it change the score.

How long should my appliance or system last?

It varies widely with build quality, maintenance, climate, water quality, and use. Published guideline ranges include roughly 7 to 15 years for a central air conditioner, 15 to 25 for a furnace, 6 to 12 for a tank water heater, and 9 to 13 for a refrigerator. A technician who has inspected your unit can give a better estimate than any average.

Is it worth repairing a 10-year-old appliance?

It depends on what failed, what it costs, and the type of equipment. Ten years is mid-life for a furnace and late-life for a dishwasher. A low-cost wear part is usually worth fixing at almost any age. A core component on equipment near the end of its expected life often is not.

What if my unit is already past its expected lifespan?

The tool assumes a repair buys at least one more year and scores accordingly, which usually leans toward replacement unless the repair is cheap. If the unit has been reliable and a technician expects more years from it, raise the expected lifespan to reflect that.

Does the calculator include energy savings from a new unit?

Only if you enter them. Savings depend on your equipment, climate, energy prices, and how much you use it, so the tool does not guess. Your utility bills and the yellow EnergyGuide label on new equipment are good starting points.

Can I use this for a roof, a car, or electronics?

Choose “Other appliance or system” and enter the expected lifespan. The cost-per-year math works for anything that wears out. For roofs, the dedicated roof repair and replacement estimators are more useful.

Reviewed October 2026. Methodology