How this estimate is built
Our source publishes installed-cost ranges by type of water heater and, separately, by tank size. It does not publish a price for a specific pairing of the two, so this estimator shows one published range at a time. The optional lines for removal, a permit, and power venting are separate pieces of work with their own published ranges, added only when you select them.
Types compared
- Storage tank — the most common and least expensive to install. Keeps a tank of water hot at all times.
- Tankless — heats water on demand. Costs more to install, and switching from a tank can require gas line, venting, or electrical upgrades.
- Heat pump (hybrid) — moves heat from the surrounding air into the water. Higher purchase price, lower running cost, and needs space and a condensate drain.
- Indirect — uses the home’s boiler as its heat source.
What moves the price
Replacing like with like in the same location is the simplest job. Costs rise when the fuel type changes, when venting must be altered, when the unit is in a tight closet or attic, or when current code requires additions such as an expansion tank, drain pan, or seismic strapping that the old installation lacked. Local labor rates and permit fees vary by area.
Sizing and incentives
Tank size should match your household’s peak hot water use, not simply the old tank. The yellow EnergyGuide label lists a first-hour rating you can compare across models. Rebates and tax credits for efficient models, especially heat pump water heaters, change often and vary by state and utility; they are not included here.
If the heater still works but is aging, the Repair vs Replace Calculator helps weigh a repair.
Common questions
How do I know the tank is failing?
Rusty water, rumbling noises from sediment, moisture around the base, and inconsistent hot water are common warning signs. A leak from the tank itself can’t be repaired.
Can I install a water heater myself?
It involves gas or high-voltage electrical connections, venting, and a pressure relief valve, and most places require a permit. Mistakes can be dangerous, so professional installation is the norm.
Reviewed October 2026. Methodology
