Roof Replacement: Cost, Materials and What to Expect

A new roof is one of the largest maintenance costs a homeowner faces. Knowing how it is priced, what the options are, and how the job runs makes the quotes far easier to judge.

What a new roof costs

This Old House reports an average of about $15,400 to replace a 2,000-square-foot roof, based on its 2026 research. Fixr’s 2026 guide gives a national average of $14,500 and a typical range of $8,000 to $36,000. Both report that labor is the largest part of the bill, at roughly 60% to 65%.

Roofers price by the “square,” which is 100 square feet of roof surface. Roof area is larger than the floor area below it because of pitch and overhangs. The Roof Replacement Cost Estimator converts your footprint and pitch to roof area and applies published ranges by material.

Materials compared

Installed cost per square foot, Fixr, January 2026
MaterialInstalled costNotes
Asphalt shingles$3–$16The most common choice. Architectural shingles are thicker and longer-lasting than 3-tab.
Metal$6–$22Long-lived and sheds snow well. Standing seam costs more than metal shingles or panels.
Wood shingles or shakes$6–$15Natural look. Needs more upkeep; restricted in some fire-prone areas.
Composite (synthetic)$7–$14Made to resemble slate or shake at lower weight.
Slate$10–$30Very durable and very heavy. The structure must be able to carry it.

The right material depends on your climate, the roof’s structure and pitch, any homeowners association or local fire rules, and how long you expect to own the home.

What else is in the price

  • Tear-off and disposal of the old roof. More layers mean more labor and dump fees.
  • Decking repair. Damaged sheathing is found only once the old roof is off. Fixr reports $150 to $1,000 or more for these repairs.
  • Underlayment, flashing, drip edge, and ventilation. These parts keep water out and are where shortcuts hide.
  • Complexity. Valleys, dormers, skylights, chimneys, and steep slopes add time.
  • Permit. Fixr reports $150 to $600, depending on location.

Repair or replace?

Local damage on an otherwise sound roof can usually be repaired. Replacement makes more sense when shingles are curling, cracked, or shedding granules across large areas, when leaks appear in several places, or when repairs have become frequent. Price a repair with the Roof Repair Cost Estimator and compare with the Repair vs Replace Calculator.

How the job goes

  1. Inspection and measurement. The roofer measures the roof and checks the attic, flashing, and ventilation.
  2. Written quote. Itemized, with product names.
  3. Permit and scheduling. Materials are delivered shortly before work starts.
  4. Tear-off. Old roofing is removed and the deck inspected. This is when hidden damage is found.
  5. Installation. Deck repairs, underlayment, flashing, roofing, ridge, and vents.
  6. Cleanup and final inspection. Including magnetic sweeps for nails.

Many asphalt roofs on simple houses are finished in a few days. Weather, size, and complexity extend that.

Comparing quotes

Get at least three, and make sure each states:

  • The exact shingle or panel product and color
  • Whether the old roof is fully removed, and how many layers
  • The price per sheet for replacing damaged decking
  • Underlayment type, and what flashing is being replaced
  • Ventilation changes
  • Manufacturer and workmanship warranty terms, in writing
  • Proof of license, where required, and of liability and workers’ compensation insurance
  • Payment schedule

A quote far below the others usually leaves something out. After a storm, be cautious with contractors who knock on doors, press for an immediate signature, or offer to cover your insurance deductible.

Sources: This Old House, “New Roof Cost,” updated September 10, 2026; Fixr, “How Much Does It Cost to Shingle a Roof?,” updated January 30, 2026.

Reviewed October 2026. Figures are national planning numbers, not quotes. Methodology